Categories: Education, Press


Published date : 12 Jul 2017


The Labour party has been exposed for “wholesale hypocrisy” on tuition fees – after announcing a hike above and beyond £9,000 for students in Wales, despite promising to scrap them during the General Election campaign just a few weeks ago.

Welsh Labour specifically stood on a manifesto promise that “there should be no tuition fees” but has proceeded with the increased levy on education regardless. UK Labour’s manifesto also specifically stated “we will abolish university tuition fees”.

The SNP has condemned Labour for failing to live up to their promises to stand up for students by scrapping these regressive charges which present a barrier to opportunity.

Labour introduced £1,000 tuition fees in 1997, before trebling them. These were increased further still under the Tories and Lib Dems to £9,000. Labour in Wales is proposing an additional increase to £9,295

The SNP made free university tuition universally available to Scottish students in 2008 and will maintain free tuition while in government.

Ruth Maguire MSP, who sits on Holyrood’s Education and Skills Committee, said:

“Labour are all talk during election campaigns – and this latest episode exposes their wholesale hypocrisy on tuition fees.

“Where they have the powers in government, instead of using them to scrap exorbitant £9,000 fees, they’ve betrayed students and young people by adding a surcharge.

“But this isn’t anything new. Labour have a murky record when it comes to tuition fees – they introduced them in the first place, have broken umpteen promises when it comes to further student support and are again gearing up to hammer students.

“And this is deeply embarrassing for Kezia Dugdale. On the same day she launches a policy targeting young people, it’s plain to see what Labour will actually do when they get into office – by robbing them of opportunies

“Scottish students know that with the SNP, no matter what their circumstances are, their education, and their chance to achieve their potential, will always be based on the ability to learn – not their ability to pay.

“And with an SNP government the number of people from our most deprived communities going on to achieve a university qualification has increased.

“We will continue to prioritise education – the most important investment we can make in our future – while Labour sell-out on their supposed values and impose prohibitive costs on students.”


Contact: SNP Media – 0131 348 5750


Tuition fees in Wales ‘could end’ if Labour win election –

TIMELINE: Can’t trust Labour on fees

1997: Ahead of the General Election, on 14 April the Evening Standard published a list of 50 questions for Tony Blair. Question six was: “Will Labour introduce tuition fees for higher education?”. Mr Blair’s response was: “Labour has no plans to introduce tuition fees for higher education.”

1998: Fees of £1000 are introduced when the Teaching and Higher Education Act is passed into law.

1999: Labour goes into power with the LibDems at Holyrood in return for stopping upfront tuition fees but they introduce a graduate endowment of £2,000 after graduation.

2001: In February ahead of the General Election, David Blunkett in his role as Education Secretary said there would be no top up fees if Labour won the election. On February 8 2001, Blunkett told MPs: “I’ve made my position clear over the past two years that I am against top-up fees. But I can now make the government’s position clear. There will be no levying of top-up fees in the next parliament if we win the next election.”

2002: In November, Margaret Hodge in her role as Higher Education Secretary told students there was “no such thing as a free lunch”. She continued: “Should the dustman continue to subsidise the doctor or should the doctor contribute towards the cost of their own education?”

2004: The maximum fee level is increased to £3000, despite a demonstration staged by 30,000 students in Trafalgar Square in London.

2005: Almost all universities set their fees at the maximum level of £3,000 per year.

2007: SNP wins Scottish Parliament elections on pledge of abolishing graduate endowment which Labour still support

2008: The graduate endowment comes to an end in Scotland on the 1st of April.

2009: Prime Minister Gordon Brown’s government commissions the Browne Review, which later leads to fees of £9,000.

2010: Labour leave office with the Browne review well underway.

2011: In March Iain Gray promises that if he is First Minister, Labour “will not introduce any up-front fees or graduate contribution for access to higher education in the lifetime of the next Parliament. There will be no price tag on education.”

2012: In September Johann Lamont announces her Cuts Commission and suggests tuition fees could be re-introduced after questioning why they are universal and not means tested.

2013: The Labour candidate in the Donside by-election – Willie Young – voices his support for tuition fees.

2014: In September during a TV debate the BBC report that Jim Murphy “could not say what his own party’s position would be in the future” on tuition fees.

2015: Almost 4 years to the day Iain Gray announced before the 2011 election that Labour would not reintroduce tuition fees Jim Murphy does exactly the same before the 2015 Westminster election.

2017: Labour in Wales indicate their plans to increase tuition fees to £9,295 – despite UK and Welsh Labour manifesto commitments to abolish tuition fees.

Local Reporters, EDUCATION

Share this post:
Website issued by Jenny Gilruth MSP, Member of the Scottish Parliament for Mid Fife & Glenrothes (SNP)

The costs of this website have been met from Parliamentary resources.
Formal feedback about website content should be sent to
The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has no responsibility for the content of externally-linked sites

12 Commercial Street, Markinch, KY7 6DE

Contact form

01592 764815 Constituency office

0131 348 5792 Edinburgh office

Privacy / Cookies & IPs

Site build:

Newsletter sign-up

Leave this field blank